See the beginning of part one for the history of this story. Comments welcome to Cgard43@hotmail.com
Later, no one could remember how the conversation started about each guy's 'first time,' but it did lead to some interesting stories.
Coach's Story
"My first time was so easy. The first guy I ever sucked was
my jock roommate in college," Coach said. "And it was not
while we were drunk or anything. I'd known for some time
that I was attracted to guys and one day my roommate
caught me checking him out as he got undressed."
"You like that, man? I mean, you like doing it with another guy?"
I said no, but then admitted I'd thought about it, but had never
tried.
"Do you?" I countered.
"Hell yes," he answered, and then pulled my pants down and
dug my cock out of my jock.
"Holy shit, man," he said, "You're really hung big."
"Then he went down on me and got about half my dick in his mouth. It felt great, of course, so when he turned around and offered me his cock, which was long but not too thick, I just went for it. I doubt I did a very good job, but we got the job done and both of us came. He was a great guy and we became best pals all through college. He was the first guy who fucked me as well, and he tried to take my cock up his ass a few times, but never got more than about half inside. He just couldn't quite do it, though what he did felt good to me anyway.
"After college, he joined the Marines and the last I heard he was living out in San Diego with another guy."
Tom's Story
"I have to say I was always pretty sure I was gay, even when
I was very young. My first time was back in high school, and
I was about 16. A buddy and I had gone skinny-dipping out at
the lake near our home and afterward we laid on the ground
and talked."
"He commented that my dick looked like it was getting hard
and I jokingly told him it was from seeing his."
"You mean that?" he asked and I said I was just joking, which of
course I wasn't.
"We just kind of looked at each other then and soon we were
stroking each other's cocks. That's all we did that first time,
but the third or fourth time we played, he took my cock in his
mouth. That felt so good that I did the same to him and we were
suck buddies from then on. We'd do it once or twice a week, at
least. It was great fun, but unfortunately about a year later
his family moved away and I lost track of him."
"Later on, when I was in college, I met a guy in the library who re-introduced me to the pleasures of sucking and later we added fucking. He was a grad student who lived off campus so we played at his place a lot. He's still a friend, though he's been involved with another guy for a number of years. We did have some fun times though before he settled down."
Al's Story
"My first time with a guy was when I was twelve. Yes, twelve.
I was at the local swimming pool and there were only two
other guys there. They were horsing around and I heard them
joking about sucking cock. Later, I walked into the changing
room and one guy was sucking the other. I ran out of there
damn fast and went home. I couldn't stop thinking about it
and the next time I was at the pool, the guard, who was
the one sucking the other guy, talked to me about it.
"He told me he was gay and liked doing it with guys. I, of
course, knew nothing about anything like that, but he
explained what guys did with each other. He didn't try to
do anything to me, but on another occasion when there were
very few people there, I saw him walk into the men's
locker area and followed him.
"I'm just curious," I said and asked if I could see his cock.
He stripped off his suit and his cock was right there in
front of me. I touched it and felt it get hard.
"Then he asked me if my dick got hard and I said yes, it's
hard right now.
"So, he showed me what it felt like to get sucked and I returned the favor. We didn't come that time, but just before the end of the summer, we did it again and that time we both came. Then he went back to college and I never saw him again.
"It wasn't until some years later that I learned there were lots of gay guys out there to play with. I don't blame the guy, but I certainly don't approve of doing it with kids, even one as willing to try it as I was."
Frank's Story
"I was about seventeen when I had my first experience, and it
wasn't exactly fun...at least not the first part of it. Three
friends and I were on a camping trip and one smart ass decided
after a beer or two that we should do a circle jerk. Though
I liked the idea of seeing all their cocks, I was somewhat
embarrassed because at least in that group I had the
biggest cock.
"One of the guys, who was a real pain in the butt, started
kidding me about how big my dick was and that just made me
more upset. As a result, I didn't shoot off when the rest of
them did and got kidded for it like crazy.
"The next week, one of the other guys invited me stay over at
his house. When we went to his bedroom after dinner, he
started teasing me about my cock.
"I told him I could come just as fast as he did and he made
me a bet.
"If I came first, he'd suck my dick, but if he did, I'd have to suck his. In hindsight, of course, he was just setting me up. I never really thought it would come to anything, but we beat our cocks and I came first. I figured my buddy would try to back out of the deal, but he didn't and put my cock in his mouth. It felt so good and my dick got so hard again, that when he suggested we suck each other, I agreed. We both came again, and the party was on. We did it twice more that night and I had a sore dick when I went home the next day.
"We stayed buddies all through school and even when we were in college, we'd occasionally get together for sex when we were home on vacation. Then his parents moved and he quit coming back to town. I really, really missed him."
Jim's Story
"I was in high school, I'd just turned 16, and one day I got
home from school earlier than usual. When I walked into the
bedroom I shared with my older brother, he and a buddy of his
were sucking each other. They were both very surprised and
embarrassed, and I was stunned.
"My brother pleaded with me not to tell our parents, and I said I wouldn't if he would suck me so I could see how it felt.
"Instead, his buddy sucked me and then asked me if I'd like to try sucking his. So I did, and soon we were all sucking each other. It was wild.
"Believe it or not, my brother and that guy have been lovers for almost fifteen years. The buddy also hooked me up with another gay friend of his and we played with each other for the rest of high school years.
"In college I never had too much trouble finding guys to play with."
Todd's Story
"I can't believe how young you guys were when you came out,"
Todd said. "I must just have been stupid or something. Oh, I
thought about it...I thought about it a lot, but until I met
that guy with the dildos I'd never known anyone who I
was sure was gay. Just think of all the years I wasted."
Tom who was sitting down the sofa from Todd reached over and put his hand on Todd's upper thigh.
"We'll be glad to help you make up for lost time, man," Tom said with a wink. Todd smiled back at him, struck again by the man's handsome face and attractive body.
"Sounds great," Todd said quietly.
Mickey's Story
"I got married when I was eighteen...to a woman, I mean. It was
a mistake and we figured it out pretty quickly. Luckily, we
didn't have any kids. After the divorce, I went into the Navy.
That's when I came out. I was working Shore Patrol with this
guy who was a few years older than me. One night after we got
off shift we went for a few drinks and one thing led to another
and we ended up in bed together. The truth is that neither
of us was drunk, but we both pretended to be and soon were
sucking each other off. I loved it when he came; I thought
it was so wild that I could make another guy come like that.
"Of course, I also liked shooting off in his mouth."
"The next day, we both pretended that nothing had happened, but about a month later, just before he was due to get out of the Navy, we were out one night and he confessed that he hadn't been drunk and wanted to know if I wanted to go to bed again. Of course I said yes, so after he got out of the service, I used to go to his place in town, and that's where I learned about other things guys can do with each other. I was so sorry when he moved back home, and except for a couple of times, we never got together again.
"When I got out, I moved here and hooked up with the State Troopers and then later met Mitch, as I told you yesterday."
Tony's Story
"My story's kind of like Coach's. I was in college. I knew I
liked guys, watched them all the time in the locker rooms and
showers, but I didn't do anything about it. After the first
semester, my roommate flunked out and I got a new guy who
I didn't know for the second semester. After a couple of
weeks, he flat out asked me if I was gay.
"Of course I denied it, but he went on to explain that he'd
seen the way I looked at other guys and just wondered. That
got me to thinking and I told him I'd thought about it but
had never done anything with another guy.
"You wanna try it?" he asked, "cause I'd like to try it with you."
"Later that night I told him I did and we spent the night
going crazy on each other's dicks. He liked it just as much as
I did and we stayed roommates for the rest of school and
then lived together for a couple of years.
"Sadly, he got transferred in his job and I didn't want to move, so we split up. But in the meantime, we had a hell of a good time. Of course it was him who taught me the joys of fucking and getting fucked."
Mitch's Story
"Well," Mitch said, "You're not going to believe this but the
first person I had sex with was a priest. No, I wasn't a
kid when it happened, and no, he didn't seduce me.
"I was pretty sure I was gay but hadn't actually done anything
with a guy. When I was 22 years old, I went, by myself, to
an adult bookstore which had a video arcade like the one we saw
today. I watched a few videos...the gay ones of course...and
finally ended up in a booth with a glory hole. That's the first
time I touched a guy's dick, and then the guy motioned for me
to stick my dick through. It felt fantastic having him go
down on me, but I was also determined to try sucking too.
So I motioned for him to give me his dick and after a few
false starts, ended up taking it in my mouth. I'm sure I wasn't
very good and the guy wanted to finish mine, so I stuck it
back through me and he sucked me until I shot. It felt
incredible.
"So I walked out and waited in the hall until the guy came out.
I couldn't believe it, but it was my priest. When he saw me,
he went white as a ghost. Then he smiled and walked over to
where I was standing."
"Your first time?" he asked.
"When I nodded, he suggested we go for coffee and talk. He didn't give me a guilt trip...he just talked about the problems with being gay and how difficult it was, and told me really to think hard about whether I was or wasn't gay.
"A couple of months later I went to see him and told him I was sure I was gay. I also asked if we could have sex again and we did. This time he gave me some pointers about how to suck and so forth. But, he refused to ever do it again after that, and that was that."
Joey's Story
"This is kind of embarrassing for me because Frank knows the
guy who was my first. He was a trainer at the gym where
Frank and I met later.
"I was pretty sure I was gay but had only touched a couple
of childhood pals when we horsed around. When I started going
to the gym, I was very attracted to this trainer, whose
name is Chris, by the way. One night I was there quite late
and the place was pretty empty. I was just walking out
of the shower when Chris walked into the locker room.
I'd been washing my cock very well and it was kind of hard
when he walked in.
"I was trying to cover myself, but there was no way to hide it.
"Big cock you've got there, man," he said.
"I just laughed, but he walked right over to me and surprised
me by taking it in his hand.
"Need some help with this thing?" he asked, and before I could
say anything, he'd sat down on the bench and sucked it
into his mouth. He sucked me for a few minutes and then
looked up at me.
"You wanna swing on mine?" he asked.
"Yeah, but I've never done that before." I told him.
"That's okay; I'll teach you how," he said, and took me into
the steam room. We both ended up doing each other.
"I did it with him a few more times, and then a year or so later I met Frank and except for Buddy Party, he's been my only sex partner since."
"I never knew you did it with Chris," Frank said, "That's amazing. He was only there for the first couple of months after I joined the gym, but I never knew he was gay."
"Well," Joey answered with grin, "He was and probably still is."
"That was a pretty good collection of stories," Al commented as he started passing out cocktails before dinner.
"Sure was," Todd said, "And it still makes me feel like I was either stupid or unlucky to never find out until I'm 29. I'm glad I didn't get married, though I dated and had sex with women, starting at about twenty. I can't say I didn't like it, but it was never as exciting as I find sex with guys now."
"It's surprising how many guys get married, even have kids and then figure out that they're gay," Al said.
"It's what we are all conditioned to do," Coach said. "It's how we're raised."
Todd told them that he'd met a married guy a few months before and recounted what John had said the night they'd met.
"He suggested that every guy should have gay sex twice before he decided to get married to a woman," Todd recounted.
"Not a bad idea," Mickey said. "I know if I'd tried it before I wouldn't have gotten married, but it just didn't happen that way."
Al served a huge pan of baked spaghetti and a big salad for dinner and everyone had their fill and pronounced it delicious. Settling down in the large family room with coffee, the conversation picked up on 'first times.'
"I keep thinking about you having a gay brother, Jim," Tony said, "Do your parents know about you both?"
"Oh yeah," Jim said, "My folks were pretty good about it. My brother told them he was gay when he was 21, and since they were in shock already, I went ahead and told them I was too."
"Double shock," Frank said with a grin.
"Oh yeah, but they were terrific about it. They said they still loved us and all that; we get along great. Of course, my Mom was relieved when my other brother and my sister both got married and started giving her grandchildren."
"I was impressed when you said your brother's been with a guy...what did you say, fifteen years?" Todd asked.
"They're a great couple. As far as I know, they are completely monogamous.
"I must say, Jim," Tom said, "Yours is the only 'first time' story I ever heard that involved a three-way. That usually comes later." Jim laughed.
"Actually, before my first Buddy Party, that was my only three-way ever."
True to the rules of the party, no one asked for details.
To be continued.