The Witch Chronicles

Published on Feb 4, 2023

Gay

The Witch Chronicles 2

Disclaimer: This Story involves all sorts of violence and homosexual activities. Just fair warning. Enjoy. And be sure to donate to keep the site running if you can.

"There's something really weird about him." I said into the receiver. I stood in the kitchen waiting on my popcorn to finish popping. As the bell dinged, I pulled the popcorn out of the microwave and passed it onto the countertop. I sighed into the phone as Charlotte and Eva went on about Lucas and his brother Finn, "But...don't you feel it? Something about them is...off."

I hadn't met Finn, but I had seen him. He seemed to have taken a liking to Eva, who seemed just as taken with him. Lucas hadn't told the whole truth when it came to Finn. The brother were twins. Identical, to be exact. Finn seemed to be the more presentable of the two and is very much a gentleman whereas his brother is a scoundrel.

"Okay, Finn and Lucas are hot. Amazingly hot. But there's something dangerous about Lucas." I stuffed popcorn into my mouth, "Are telling me that you haven't sensed something totally batshit about him?"

Charlotte countered my statement by reminding me that I had just said that Lucas was hot. She theorized that I was doing what I normally did to people I was attracted to: Vilify them. She also pointed out that I hadn't done that with David.

"Okay, it might not be such a stretch to think I have a slight attraction to the guy. It's not a stretch at all, but come on." I sat the bag of popcorn, "He's...he scares me."

"Scares? Or excites?" Eva asked.

I sighed. They knew me better than anyone else in the world. I told them both that I had to go and hung up the phone. I sat the phone on the table and began stuffing more popcorn in my mouth. The thought of liking someone else was a terrifying thought. The fact that David was supposed to come back to school tomorrow was even worse. Now Eva and I could be cowards together.

Chapter 2: All You Had to do is Stay

July 2

"Are you sure about this?" David asked.

It was always about fun. The thrill of the chase, the absolute feeling disconnect that I felt with him. At the beginning of sophomore year, I was surprised when David took interest in me. It started off slowly, first with texts and IM's and escalating to hanging out and eventually we were friends.

I thought I was insane about my feelings until he took the initiative to cross the line. And I let him.

After a while of making out, we were brought to a defining moment. The point where making out and stealing kisses turns into something more physical and life-changing than I was used to. The tides had turned in whatever relationship we had.

But it was my decision. And I didn't regret it.

What I regretted was the moment after it when I had to learn the truth about love and relationships.

As I rest on his chest, I felt more at home than I had in a while. It was a weird feeling to feel him pull away and even weirder to feel him get to his feet and begin to dress. I watched on, trying not to worry.

When he was done, it was like he couldn't look at me. I began to wonder if it was shame or had I not done something right. When he left without a word, I felt ashamed and dirty and a bit confused.

-           

After receiving a course load that could stifle a horse, I found myself sitting under a tree with a copy of The Color Purple. I had read the book, watched the movie and become enamored with overall theme of the book. The characters were compelling, too. I didn't have a least favorite character. I must look like an idiot re-reading it every year.

I rarely a book or watched a movie more than once. If I did, you could tell I really liked it. The same could be said for people. My friends were only my friends because I genuinely liked them.

This train of thought brought me to my conversation with Jason and the argument with Lucas afterward. He pictured himself an authority on my relationship with Jason based on what he gleamed from watching. It wasn't quite a shock. There had to be something wrong with someone so...perfect.

It was no shock either that he showed up to gawk at me.

"I think it pisses God off if you walk by the color purple in a field somewhere and don't notice it." Lucas said as he walked up to me. His trademark smirk ever present on his face, "Of course, God isn't real..."

"What do you want?" I asked as I looked up at him for the first time.

"I think we got off on the wrong feet." He said with a strained voice. Obviously apologies aren't his strong suit, "I took a conversation that I shouldn't have been listening to and jumped to a hell of a conclusion."

"Of course you did. I doubt it's the first time." I said with a shrug. He stared at me with a look of surprise. When his expression softened, he was smiling. I rolled my eyes, "What is it that you want from me, exactly? First you jump to conclusions about my relationship with my best friend's brother and now you're apologizing, but do you even know why you're apologizing?"

"Not exactly. I don't usually apologize for truthful statements."

"So why apologize?" I asked.

"Because it's what you wanted to hear." Lucas said truthfully.

"Finally. Now that's you." I said closing the book and standing, "Look, I find you unnerving, to say the least. I don't quite understand it, but I feel like...There's something off about you. And, in general, I'm inclined to decline whatever it is you want. Sorry."

I said nothing more as I walked past. With the sins of my past threatening to tear me apart, I was off to History. I believe firmly in the old adage about not knowing history leading to repeating it. I didn't want to repeat history. I wanted to make it.

-           

July 3

It had been twenty hours, seventeen minute and forty two seconds since I'd lost my virginity to David Gilbert. I hadn't received so much as a text, even though I had sent many. If I were watching myself in a movie or reading myself in a book, I would feel embarrassed for myself.

The toll it took on me was obvious to everyone, especially Eva and Charlotte. They badgered me the whole day, until I was able to move them past whatever I was going through. I was titanium. I smiled and laughed, though I felt as if I were about to fall apart.

"I think I should dye my hair auburn? Maybe streak it?" Charlotte said as she picked at her hair in my mirror.

"Auburn? What about red? Or strawberry?" Eva asked as she joined her at mirror, "You have to ease into a darker color. That's like me going full-on blonde."

"I can't see you as a blonde." Charlotte said thoughtfully, "Perry, what do you think."

They both looked at me through the mirror. I was too quiet for my own good. When I looked up at them, I was surprised to find them both looking at me. They both turned to me and I panicked. When I was about to freak out, Eva's eyes went to my feet.

"What's that?" Eva said as she literally dove at my feet. When she stood, she was holding an opened condom wrapper. Her eyes went wide as they found me again, "Wha—When?"

"Who?" Charlotte asked as she stood at the mirror.

"David." I said sheepishly.

"Gilbert? I thought you weren't...you are friends." Charlotte said softly, "Why him? He's a jerk."

"Charlotte!" Eva warned, "Perry, you...did you like it? You were obviously careful. Tell us all about it."

"On second thought, don't." Charlotte frowned.

We both stared at her, neither of us either to dispute her comments or the fact that she was right. I wasn't surprised by Charlotte's adverse action to David. We all had a certain distaste for him.

"Look, I know we need to be positive about this because it's your first time, but..." Charlotte trailed. Eva glared at her and she took a seat my computer desk, "How was it?"

"The actual sex was great." I said quickly. Both girls watched me intently, "He left after. He hasn't returned my texts."

The girls exchanged nervous expressions before their attention turned to me again. Eva moved over and sat next to me. She put her arm around my shoulder.

"Are you okay?" She asked.

"Not sure." I said softly.

"Is there anything we can do?" Charlotte asked.

"No. I think it's sufficiently up to David."

-           

After a round of classes, I found myself reading again. To avoid further misconception, I put on headphones and let Sam Smith croon in my ear. I felt very displaced in time. Charlotte and Eva were already at cheerleading, which I opted out of, despite a very tempting offer to join. The cheerleaders were always looking for new guys. I wouldn't be very good at it.

The thought crossed my mind that I should join some sort of activity. My grades were above average but going into college, I would no doubt need more than good grades. Then again, I could always become a hermit and run off into the woods.

Modesty.

As I turned the page to my novel, I felt someone take a seat across from me. I groaned as I looked up to see Parker. He seemed nervous about something and I didn't have to take a guess where this conversation was going. I felt his nervousness as if it were something tangible.

Parker beamed at me before stammering, "Hello." I stared at him, waiting for him to wipe the dumb smile off his face. He chuckled nervously and cleared his throat, "Okay. Right to it, then? I was wondering if—is Eva seeing anyone?"

"Seeing?"

"Dating. Talking to..."

"Screwing?" I asked.

"Well, yeah." Parker's face darkened.

"No. Not seriously." I said with a shrug, "Look, Parker, Eva's a big girl. She makes her own choices. Whatever hold you think I have over her isn't really true."

"Maybe. Or maybe you're underestimating yourself. It was a long shot." Parker said as he stood.

"Hey, Park." I said catching his attention, "Don't think this is me coming onto you or anything, but you're a good guy. Not going to lie, losing her is your loss but her losing you is hers."

"Thanks." He said with a nod. He soon disappeared into the crowd of individuals.

I put my headphones back in and continued with the novel. I was just getting to the best part.

-           

July 4th

Fireworks.

The fourth of July festival was the biggest thing to hit Majestic Hills all year. All the parents would get drunk and relive their glory days while the kids set off fireworks. The teenagers, as we are, we eventually sneak off into the woods for our own party.

The party, of course, always hit some kind of hiccup. This year it was the looming threat of a thunderstorm. Of course, there was also the fact that I hadn't heard from David in two days. My expectations were severely lowered, though Eva told me to be hopeful. She always thought I should be optimistic about everything.

It was no surprise that I celebrated the fourth with her and Charlotte, as well as a reluctant Jason. After our mini-celebration, we left for the bigger party. While we were there, I broke away from Eva and Charlotte and found myself venturing further into the woods.

Stumbling, I made my way into a clearing. When I found a log to sit on, I looked down the beach to see a couple making out on a beach towel in the sand. I watched in utter embarrassment. I thought PDA was pretty tacky. It was only by the grace of moonlight that I caught a glimpse of one of the teenagers, David Gilbert.

I felt my stomach twist in knots and reached down to calm it as I stood. By a weird stroke of misfortune, he spotted me. I turned to walk away from the spot, content with never seeing him again.

The next couple of weeks, I ignored more than a few of his texts. I hadn't seen him since.

-           

As I prepared to make my hasty retreat, I got a call from Eva and Charlotte who told me that they'd meet me at Charlotte's house at six. I agreed and told them to be careful. After hanging up, I made my way to the parking lot.

I rummaged around my messenger bag and tossed books around until I fished my keys out and held them up in celebration for my success. As I neared my car, I nearly froze in surprise when I saw that David was leaning on my car.

As I walked closer, David stood straight up and scratched the back of his head. I noticed that his arm was bandaged and he seemed more edgy than usual.

"Hey."

I stared at him.

"I've always liked this car. Challenger, 2011, right?" He asked.

"2010."

He nodded and walked past me.

"I'm glad you didn't get mauled." I said softly.

He stopped and turned to me, "Can we go back? Or even start over?" He asked.

"To before you slept with me, didn't call and screwed around with—"

"Me and you aren't—we weren't together." David groaned, "We agreed when this thing started that it was about fun. We're having fun."

"We aren't having fun. Do you think it was fun to see you with anybody after I—I never did that with anyone. I am not the type of person who does that. I don't give—" I stopped. I was so angry that I was near tears but I stopped before I regressed into tears, "I see people do this all the time...to be friends with benefits or have fun and I tried."

"I'm not...You're the only guy I've ever been with." David's voice was low but chaotic, "I don't like guys. I like you but I don't want...this."

"This?" I asked.

"You know what I mean."

"Me?" I asked.

"Can't we just—"

"Listen, I'll make this easy for you. I wish I was that type of person but I'm just not. You don't have to be this. I'll be this." I said as I turned from him.

I closed my eyes, trying to contain every emotion I was feeling. I pushed it down and climbed into my car. I could see him in the rearview, walking back towards the school. I pulled my car out and sped away from the school, feeling utterly drained.

Author's Notes: Please feel free to E-Mail if you like the story at Femtoka2@yahoo.com to let me know you like it and how you feel about the story. Thank you for reading!

Next: Chapter 3


Rate this story

Liked this story?

Nifty is entirely volunteer-run and relies on people like you to keep the site running. Please support the Nifty Archive and keep this content available to all!

Donate to The Nifty Archive